California Legal Research

Judge comparison

HEKvs.Jonathan Fish

	HEK	Jonathan Fish
Total rulings	100	14
Counties active	1	1
Grant rate	31%	57%
Deny rate	11%	7%
Continued	9%	7%
Plaintiff wins	58%	50%
Defendant wins	28%	10%
Mixed outcomes	14%	40%

Common motion types — grant rate

Motion type	HEK	Jonathan Fish
Other	45 · 27% granted	6 · 67% granted
Demurrer	24 · 8% granted	2 · 0% granted
Motion for Summary Judgment	8 · 88% granted	3 · 33% granted
Motion to Strike	9 · 44% granted	1 · 0% granted
Motion to Compel Further Responses	5 · 40% granted	2 · 50% granted
Motion for Summary Adjudication	4 · 50% granted	3 · 33% granted
Motion for Sanctions	3 · 67% granted	1 · 100% granted
Motion to Compel Discovery	2 · 100% granted	2 · 100% granted
Motion for Attorney Fees	3 · 100% granted	—
Motion to Quash	3 · 0% granted	—
Motion for Reconsideration	2 · 50% granted	1 · 100% granted
Petition	1 · 0% granted	1 · 100% granted

Comparisons are descriptive, not predictive. Sample sizes and case mix differ; weigh accordingly.