Judge comparison

COMMISSIONER CHRISTINE S. DEHRvs.Cynthia P. Smith

Name: California Superior Court Tentative Rulings
Creator: DecisionDepot
License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/

	COMMISSIONER CHRISTINE S. DEHR	Cynthia P. Smith
Total rulings	20	239
Counties active	1	1
Grant rate	35%	33%
Deny rate	5%	6%
Continued	0%	28%
Plaintiff wins	44%	34%
Defendant wins	33%	36%
Mixed outcomes	22%	30%

Common motion types — grant rate

Motion type	COMMISSIONER CHRISTINE S. DEHR	Cynthia P. Smith
Other	9 · 44% granted	99 · 29% granted
Petition	1 · 100% granted	95 · 40% granted
Demurrer	5 · 0% granted	21 · 0% granted
Motion to Compel Discovery	2 · 50% granted	13 · 46% granted
Motion to Strike	4 · 0% granted	9 · 0% granted
Motion for Sanctions	4 · 50% granted	7 · 43% granted
Motion to Compel Further Responses	1 · 100% granted	10 · 50% granted
Motion to Quash	2 · 50% granted	5 · 80% granted
Anti-SLAPP Motion	1 · 0% granted	5 · 20% granted
Motion for Summary Adjudication	1 · 0% granted	3 · 67% granted

Comparisons are descriptive, not predictive. Sample sizes and case mix differ; weigh accordingly.